Ninaithale Inikkum offers a nostalgic trip into college life, with a story that balances romance and friendship effectively. The screenplay is straightforward, though it occasionally falls into predictable patterns, especially in the second half. The pacing in the first half is engaging, setting up the characters and their relationships well, but the second half slows down with extended emotional sequences that may test the viewer's patience.

The songs and music, though not credited here, play a significant role in enhancing the emotional depth of the film. The soundtrack complements the youthful and sentimental tone, with melodious tracks that resonate with the theme of nostalgia. The background score supports the narrative but does not stand out as a major highlight.

Cinematography by Balasubramaniem captures the college atmosphere and scenic locations with a warm and inviting palette, adding to the film's overall appeal. While the film does not break new ground in storytelling, it succeeds in delivering a heartfelt experience for audiences who appreciate coming-of-age dramas with a musical touch.

Prithviraj Sukumaran: Delivers a sincere and relatable portrayal of the protagonist, balancing charm and emotional depth.

Priyamani: Offers a natural and engaging performance, effectively conveying the nuances of her character.

Karthik Kumar: Provides solid support with a nuanced take on his role, adding to the group dynamics.

K. Bhagyaraj: Brings experience and subtle humor, enriching the narrative with his presence.