Itha Innu Muthal presents a storyline that is engaging in parts but follows a conventional narrative arc common to Malayalam films of its era. The screenplay maintains a steady pace, with the first half focusing on character introductions and setting up the comedic and dramatic elements. The second half attempts to resolve the conflicts but tends to slow down, affecting the overall momentum.

The film's content balances humor and sentiment, though some sequences feel stretched, impacting the pacing negatively. The absence of a noted music director and songs in the available data suggests that the film relies more on its narrative and performances rather than musical appeal. The background score, while functional, does not stand out significantly, serving primarily to support the scenes without drawing attention.

Cinematography by C E Babu captures the essence of the period and setting adequately, though it does not bring any innovative visual style. Overall, the movie is a modest entertainer with moments of charm but lacks the depth or technical finesse to elevate it beyond an average viewing experience.

Shankar: Delivered a competent and earnest portrayal of his character, fitting well within the film's tone.

Sreenath: Provided solid support with a natural performance, contributing to the film's comedic and dramatic balance.

Rani Padmini: Brought grace and emotional depth to her role, enhancing the relational dynamics.

Bhuvana Saravana: Played her part with sincerity, though with limited scope.

Jagathy Sreekumar: Added significant comic relief with his timing and expressions, a highlight of the film.

Sukumari: Delivered a strong supporting role with her characteristic presence and nuance.